Favoritism in the Workplace: Is It Illegal?

Playing favorites in the workplace may be illegal; it all depends on why some employees are favored and others are not.

Updated by , J.D., University of Missouri School of Law

There's no question that favoritism is a bad management practice: It breeds resentment, destroys employee morale, and creates disincentives for good performance. Once employees see that benefits flow from being on the manager's good siderather than from doing a great jobthere's little point in working hard.

And favoritism leads to lost productivity, as employees who aren't getting the plum assignments spend more and more time gossiping and griping about how unfair the system is rather than doing their work.

But is favoritism illegal? Not always. It depends on why employees are being favored or disfavored. No law prevents companies from having lousy managers or running a workplace like a schoolyard. If favoritism is rooted in discrimination, harassment, or retaliation, however, it crosses the line from poor management to illegal behavior.

Favoritism as Illegal Discrimination

Illegal discrimination happens when employers make job decisions based on employees' protected characteristicstraits that federal, state, or local governments have decided should not be the basis for employment actions.

Under federal law, for example, it's illegal for employers not to hire someone because of his race, to refuse to promote women, to relegate employees with disabilities to low-paying positions, or to lay off employees based on age.

If workplace favoritism is based on protected characteristics, then it is illegal discrimination. For example, if a manager promotes only men or gives the best assignments and shifts to employees who share his religious beliefs, that would be discrimination.

On the other hand, favoritism that's based on other factors may not be discriminatory, even if it's a sign of bad management. For example, if a manager favors employees who are her college buddies, who are fans of the same baseball team, or who love the same band, that is not illegal discrimination.

Favoritism as Sexual Harassment

The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), the federal agency that interprets and enforces the laws prohibiting discrimination, has said that favoritism may be sexual harassment if it's based on submitting to a manager's sexual advances. For example, if some employees receive better assignments or other job benefits because they put up with a manager's harassment, the other employees may still have a legal claim against the company.

Because putting up with harassment is a condition of getting job benefits, employees may have a valid sexual harassment claim, whether or not they were directly subjected to harassment or went along with it.

Some courts have gone further and found that favoring romantic partners in the workplace may constitute sexual harassment in some situations. Even if the romantic partners themselves are not facing harassment (because their relationships are consensual), other employees may believe that the only way to get ahead at the company is to have a sexual relationship with the boss.

At some point, this type of behavior crosses the line from unprofessional to illegal harassment, particularly if a number of employees are involved.

Favoritism as Retaliation

If a manager's decisions are intended to punish employees who have complained of illegal behavior (such as discrimination, harassment, or unsafe working conditions), that could be illegal retaliation.

For example, if a group of employees have filed an OSHA complaint because their employer isn't providing them with required safety equipment, and their manager reserves the best assignments for employees who have not joined the complaint, that is a form of illegal retaliation.

Similarly, if a manager disfavors an employee (for example, by cutting back her hours, assigning her to the graveyard shift, or taking away prestigious clients) after she complains of harassment, that would also be illegal retaliation.

How to Handle Workplace Favoritism

There are several ways—short of filing a lawsuit—to respond to favoritism in the workplace. Here are a few of the best approaches:

  • Address the situation directly. Calmly express your concerns to the person showing favoritism, focusing on your own feelings and observations. Rather than making accusations, use "I" statements to convey your own perspective. For example: "I've noticed that certain people seem to receive more opportunities than I do, and it's making me feel undervalued. I want to understand why this might be happening, and what we might do to fix this."
  • Discuss the matter with human resources. If addressing the issue directly doesn't lead to a satisfactory resolution, consider speaking with your HR representative. Provide specific examples of the favoritism you've witnessed. Emphasize how the situation is affecting your morale and performance, and inquire about the company's policies regarding fairness and equal treatment.
  • Focus on your own performance. Try not to let workplace favoritism consume your thoughts or affect your work negatively. Set goals for yourself and actively seek out opportunities for growth and advancement. By consistently delivering high-quality work and demonstrating your value to the team, you can potentially earn recognition and opportunities despite any favoritism present.

    Next Steps

    If your employer allows favoritism to run rampant, you may want to consult with an experienced employment lawyer to decide whether it's worth filing a lawsuit. A lawyer can review your case and determine whether favoritism has crossed the line from ineffective management to illegal behavior.

    You can use our Lawyer Directory to find an employment law attorney in your area.

    Get Professional Help
    Talk to an Employment Rights attorney.
    There was a problem with the submission. Please refresh the page and try again
    Full Name is required
    Email is required
    Please enter a valid Email
    Phone Number is required
    Please enter a valid Phone Number
    Zip Code is required
    Please add a valid Zip Code
    Please enter a valid Case Description
    Description is required

    How It Works

    1. Briefly tell us about your case
    2. Provide your contact information
    3. Choose attorneys to contact you